The movie was terrible. Not just misunderstood or a noble failure, but the kind of terrible that makes you question whether everyone involved had seen the same script. Jay and I settled in, him with the remote and me with a defensively large bowl of popcorn. “What are we expecting?” he asked. “Atmosphere and regret,” I replied. We were both correct.
The opening scene was beautiful, which should have been the first warning. The house had tall windows, impossible furniture, and enough candles to suggest the characters had never received an electrical bill. A woman walked down a hallway in a coat that deserved a better screenplay. The music behaved as though a tragedy had already occurred, though the only thing on screen was a car arriving slowly. I said, “The coat is going to have to carry this.” Jay said, “It has the shoulders for it.” Ten minutes later, the main character made a decision no person with access to a phone, a vehicle, or a basic sense of self-preservation would make. We paused, not because we needed clarification. We needed to object as a household.
The snacks were already here, which had nothing to do with the rental fee, but sounded financially responsible in the moment. We arranged the room anyway. Lights lowered, drinks nearby, a bowl of something salty between us. I had changed into clothes that said the public no longer had access to me. Jay had the remote, which is usually wise because I pause a movie to discuss production design and then behave surprised when the runtime becomes an evening commitment.
The movie began with a title card so serious that I almost laughed before the first scene. Then a character delivered information nobody would say aloud unless they knew an audience was present. Jay looked at me. I looked at him. We both understood that the evening had changed categories. At first, I tried to remain respectful. Maybe the awkward dialogue was setting something up. Maybe the unexplained necklace mattered. Maybe the camera lingering on a decorative bird would pay off later. I have faith in a visual motif. I will give a suspicious vase 40 minutes to become relevant. The vase did not become relevant.
A character made a decision so unreasonable that I sat forward and said, “Oh, now we are cooking.” That is when the movie became fun. The character had heard a sound upstairs after being explicitly told that nobody was upstairs. Instead of leaving the house, calling for help, or even turning on a light, she picked up one decorative candle and began climbing. I sat forward. Jay said, “No, no, not to me, to her.” Though I felt included, the music had started announcing danger before she reached the first step. A portrait on the wall appeared to follow her with its eyes, which would have been alarming if the portrait had not looked mildly embarrassed to be involved.
People often use bad and boring as though they are the same judgment. They are not. A boring movie can be technically competent. Everyone knows their lines. The images are clean. The story arrives where it said it would. Nothing is wrong enough to become interesting. A bad movie can be alive. It can reach for something ridiculous and miss with enough force to create weather. It can contain a performance delivered at a volume the rest of the cast did not agree to. It can build a world with rules that change whenever the script becomes inconvenienced. It can place a chandelier in a room simply because somebody believed the chandelier had earned work.
Critics are right to judge a film by whether it accomplishes what it attempts. I am also allowed to judge a night by whether I enjoyed living through it. Those are not the same review. People call anything excessive camp now. And I would like the Department of Language to investigate. Camp is not simply bright color, bad acting, or a person wearing feathers. It has a relationship to style, seriousness, performance, failure, artifice, and the delicious distance between what a thing believes it is doing and what we receive.
The movie ended with a twist that explained less than it believed. A character stared into the camera. The music rose. The screen cut to black with the confidence of a film that expected us to be stunned. Jay said, “What?” I said, “Exactly.” We sat through part of the credits because we were trying to determine whether there was another scene or whether the movie had simply left. I opened the review app. This is a habit. I wanted to see whether other people had noticed the vase, the staircase, the confession, the wig, the red wine, and the fact that one character had changed motivation between rooms. The reviews were vicious and funny. Some were more entertaining than the movie. One person had written a single sentence that explained the plot better than the screenplay had. I hovered over the rating. Technically, the movie was not good. I had enjoyed myself completely. How do you rate that?
After everybody left, the room looked like evidence of a successful gathering. Empty cups. A bowl with three pieces of popcorn nobody wanted enough to finish. One blanket on the floor because somebody had gotten hot during the final act and thrown it off with more conviction than any character displayed on screen. Jay asked whether I would recommend the movie. I said yes, but only with conditions. You need people who understand that questions will not receive answers. You need snacks sturdy enough to survive disappointment. You need at least one person willing to defend a performance that belongs to another film. And nobody can enter expecting silence because silence would leave the movie alone with what it had done.
